Stopping Sham Unions In New YorkJanuary 29, 2019
“These bills represent a real response to what private sanitation workers have been reporting for years—that fake, sham unions have cropped up throughout the waste industry, allowing some of the most notorious employers to continue to work with individuals who have been banned from the industry for links to organized crime. These bills close a loophole in BIC’s authority to rid the industry of corruption, and hopefully represent the first step in raising labor standards in what has been a race-to-the-bottom industry,” said Melissa Iachan, Senior Staff Attorney at New York Lawyers for the Public Interest.
The legislation follows the use of a sham union by Sanitation Salvage, the disgraced company shut down last November after worker deaths, to prevent workers getting proper union representation. Melissa testified in support of the legislation, and you can read her full testimony here.
Pedro Garcia, a 21-year-old former Sanitation Salvage employee, said, “The union voted on a contract that they didn’t even consult with us on. When I asked them why they did that, he said right to my face, ‘We came up with a contract that benefits the employer,’ and I said, ‘I thought you were supposed to represent us’”.
Reynoso said, “Sham unions negotiate with the employers about what they’re going to give to the workers, and the workers don’t even know they belong to a union. They don’t think that there’s anyone out there to protect them”.
By not being represented by a real union, many Sanitation Salvage workers were subject to conditions like not getting workers compensation, no job security, no gear provided, no health insurance, and exploitation of labor. Many of the workers testified that they spent more time working on the truck than they did with their own families.
Manuel Matiras, a former Sanitation Salvage worker, said: “The starting salary was $65/night for 1,500 stops. It wouldn’t matter if it took you five or 15 hours. You just had to get the work done”.
Several workers made similar statements about exploitation of labor.
Many council members expressed the same interest in a need for a bill that would halt the growth of sham unions and protect workers rights. Council Member Jumaane Williams said: “In an industry where workers’ rights abuses are widespread and issues such as wage theft are all too common, we in the city need to take a stand and enact protections for people who undertake this difficult work for our city”.
The conference ended with the workers chanting in unison, “When workers fight, workers win!”.
Standing with @CMReynoso34 @cmenchaca @TeamstersJC16 @ALIGNny @NYCEJAlliance @NYLPI @NRDCNY in support of @NYCCouncil bills that will help put an end to corrupt sham unions & dangerous practices that jeopardize the lives of workers in the private carting industry. pic.twitter.com/Fll7U2V2iM
— (((Rory Lancman))) (@RoryLancman) January 29, 2019
Today we rallied on behalf of private sanitation workers who have been exploited for far too long. Thank you to all of my partners in this fight including my @NYCCouncil colleagues for their support. pic.twitter.com/TnBDU2MHzR
— Antonio Reynoso (@CMReynoso34) January 29, 2019
“I sometimes started working at 6:30 PM and wouldn’t be done until 11 AM the next day. I’ve never worked that hard in my life and I’m only 24 years old.” – John Rojas, former Sanitation Salvage Worker pic.twitter.com/cPFrwZsLjo
— Don’t Trash NYC (@donttrashnyc) January 29, 2019
Here’s what you can do right now for justice in New York…
Stay up to date
Get updates on our cases and campaigns, and join us in taking action for justice…