We Support NYC’s Proposed 5-Cent-Fee on Single Use Paper Carryout Bags

April 16, 2019

Environmental Justice, News

New York state recently banned the use of disposable plastic bags, but left it up to cities to decide whether to charge an additional fee on other disposable single use bags, which has been shown to be much more effective in reducing the amount of waste produced.

NYLPI Senior Staff Attorney Melissa Iachan testified before New York City Council today in support of New York City’s proposed five cent fee on single use paper carryout bags:

We are thrilled that the state has passed a ban on plastic bags, which are a scourge to our environment on many levels. However, all precedent indicates that to truly reduce single-use disposable bag use by consumers, the statewide ban should be accompanied by a fee on other single use bags such as paper bags.

What’s more, we know that this formula—plastic bag ban with a fee on other single-use bags—works. In Portland, OR, a plastic bag ban without a fee on paper resulted in a 491% increase in paper bag use, and an almost $5 million increase in the cost of bags. This makes no sense for any city, environmentally or financially. Meanwhile, a plastic bag ban with a 10 cent charge on paper reduced paper bag use by 30% in the first year of LA County’s bag ban. The charge also offsets the stores’ costs of distributing paper bags, which can be two or more times as expensive as plastic bags.  Additionally, where a fee/ban hybrid has been established, costs of fixing recycling sorting machinery from tangled plastic bags has been reduced by several million dollars, as have sanitation department costs for collection and disposal of these bags.

You can read Melissa’s full testimony here.





Related Content

The Guardian Covers NYLPI Sports Equity Suit The piece, by journalist Matthew Hall, focuses on NYLPI's suit through the lens of student efforts to secure sports teams.
Fair Play Lobby Day Brings New York City Public School Students to City Hall to Demand Equity in Access to Sports Teams Students will demand an end to racially discriminatory sports team allocations by the Public School Athletic League.
Advocates Call for Stronger Commercial Waste Reforms after City Study Shows Benefits City shows exclusive waste zoning would bring traffic, pollution reductions, double recycling rates, and create green jobs.

Take Action

Here’s what you can do right now for justice in New York…

Stay up to date

Get updates on our cases and campaigns, and join us in taking action for justice…

Stay Connected

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and opportunities to take action from our team.

Thanks! We’ll be in touch soon!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!